Sifting through the tweets tagged with #riotcleanup there is swift equivocation: at once the physical act of clearing rubble from the streets merges with the act of cleansing the street of black youths. The cleaning of streets amounts to the wiping away of traces of social unrest. Cracks in society are smoothed over and at once an oppressed underclass is rendered invisible again.
Commentator after commentator has described the rioters as “animals” and “feral rats”. The videos of these statements are repeated perpetually on news channels. The message: these rioters are not humans. The demand: that they not be treated as human. The ideology of hate is drummed into our skulls, and unsurprisingly the chatter of the social media responds by saying that those involved should be locked up, and the key thrown away. Or, perhaps more concerningly, that they should be subject to the street justice of vigilante action.
The reward offered for such action is “true community”, or “community spirit.” In the face of such rampant dehumanization, these new communities, the battalions of #riotcleanup, reassert their supposed true humanity. And such a new humanity is a badge to be worn with pride. It is forgotten by many that it is premised on exclusion, on the sweeping away of neighbours. Raise your broom to the sky and create the world anew, a world without unrest in the face of poverty and oppression. A world in which black youths, and the real antagonisms of society, are consigned to oblivion.
Last night the first of the major vigilante actions to come took place in Enfield. According to reports, a group of middle-aged white men ran up the streets proclaiming, “We are English, we are English.” Their aim was to terrorise those who had been involved in unrest the night before, and in the process the notion of an exclusive new community was transformed into the abuse of those not born in England. In other tweets under the #riotcleanup tag similar politics have been presented, mainly focusing on poor black communities. The English Defence League are also reported to be interested in playing a leading role in these “community” actions.
Meanwhile, in Clapham, people gathered together on streets, brooms raised. Boris arrived, giving a rousing speech and the crowd (mainly white, middle-class, and middle-aged) applaudedthemselves, not as individuals who had decided to clean the streets, but as an exclusive collective of true citizens.
In 1921, Freud wrote one of the most penetrating and insightful texts of the early twentieth-century: On Mass Psychology and the Analysis of the Ego. Freud offers analysis of the church and the army as forms of groups that centre themselves around not only a type of exclusivity but on a relation to an ideal version of an object. It was but a short step from here, in Italy and in Germany that this idealized object was the future in which the exclusionary nature of the group was made manifest and total, in the form of fascism. For this reason, Wilhelm Reich’s 1933 book, The Mass-Psychology of Fascism, borrowed heavily from Freud.
It is this structure of “community”, and “clean up” as the activity of this group, that an old form of popular fascism appears to be revitalized. The new communities of #riotcleanup again make their exclusionary nature clear: these people work not for all, and certainly not for the wellbeing of those who caused the unrest – to work against the poverty and racism – instead, they work for themselves, as a group, and their new society. They call this “The Big Society”, but the truth is that the Big Society can never be big enough. As the cause of #riotcleanup becomes the first mass-venture in the Big Society, it shows itself to be nothing more than an organized mode of social exclusion that reaffirms existing economic exclusion. Its first victims are the black, the poor, the young, and the unemployed.
Frequently modern fascism is modeled as a post-human technocracy: Marx’s description of the human as a mere appendage to a machine elevated to a rule. Today we need to reassess these thoughts, as under the label of #riotcleanup an older ideology-based fascism is being restored. Unlike dystopic fantasies of a borg-like matrix, it is now necessary to start questioning the fascistic nature of “community” as it is manifest in the response to the riots. This should be a matter of grave concern for all who wish to have an inclusive society, free from prejudice.
taken from: http://thethirdestate.net/


I think you are right. The sight of the clean ups made me feel uneasy. Good blog.
You need to get out more.
spot on ! one other thing that is also making me really sick is this “pat a turk on the back attitude for protecting us ” going on in dalston right now . as if to reward the turkish community for “good behaviour ” . sick sick sick !!
this is from the very people that moved to dalston because it was now trendy . not giving a damn that the rents in dalston are so high now , making it hugely impossible for people that have lived in the area for decades to sustain living in the area . these are the very people who will be opening trendy shops in dalston which will eventually drive the turkish businesses away . they couldn’t care less about turkish people or the turkish community .
This is a shit article for multiple reasons. The nature of the positive feedback in the comment above speaks volumes. Started off quite promising but quickly descended.
You guys really are on another planet. With this kind of cod-theorising, I can equally say that the rioters recall a fascist physiognomy, as they really did behave like SS blackshirts smashing up and ransacking successful Jewish businesses. Mob mentality – no justification for the damaging and pillaging of businesses, people’s property and damaging livelihoods.
Perhaps you think that the Muslim and Sikhs in Birmingham who protected and defended their livlihoods, and paid the price with the murder of 3 hardworking young men by a rioter, displays a “fascist physiognomy”. Your analysis really is a bad example of higher education study, and probably justifies cutting whatever course you studied on.
this is an article about the riot cleanup commenting on the white middle class (sourced, if you’ll take a closer look, from another blog)
the tragic murder of those 3 young men is an utterly different issue which, as indicated by the bbc, seems to have stemmed from racial tensions in the area.
you seem to be flailing your criticism towards anything which involves race and the connections arent logically sound. quite a flaccid and immature choice of ending to your comment too.
Welcome to the Big Broom Society. Our motto: ‘Sweeping social problems under the carpet’. Middle class, well educated people with good jobs and mortgages will simply no longer stand for loutish behaviour in deprived inner city areas with good transport links. These hooligans care nothing for rising property values in their own communities!
For disturbing instance of racist vigilante action see http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VeX8y0JQNqI
All this talk of community reflects a political vacuum which fascism and the God squad will try to fill
So it’s OK to clean up your neighbourhood if you’re Asian or Kurdish, but fascist if you’re doing the same in a white middle-class area? That is just plain stupid and patronising to black people and migrant communities.